Florida's Cat Fund: Don't Eliminate the Surcharge. Make It Work for Policyholders.

Florida homeowners desperately need relief from rising property insurance premiums. There is little disagreement about that. However, the question is how we provide meaningful relief without exposing those same homeowners to even greater financial burdens following the next major hurricane. Reducing insurance costs today means very little if we create a financial problem that costs policyholders substantially more tomorrow.

Governor-elect Byron Donalds has proposed eliminating the 25% cash build-up factor associated with the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund (FHCF). In an October 2026 interview with Fox News, Donalds argued that repealing the surcharge would automatically begin lowering property insurance premiums. While I agree that Florida homeowners deserve to benefit from lower reinsurance expenses, I believe there is a more responsible approach that protects the Cat Fund while ensuring those savings actually reach policyholders.

My proposal is straightforward: Keep the 25% cash build-up factor until the Cat Fund reaches its established reserve target. Once that target is reached, automatically suspend the surcharge and require insurance companies to issue refund checks for the actual savings.

Understanding the Cat Fund

The Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund was established to provide a stable source of hurricane reinsurance to participating residential property insurance companies. Instead of relying exclusively on private reinsurance markets, insurers can purchase certain hurricane reinsurance coverage through the state-administered Fund. This helps support Florida's property insurance market by providing coverage that might otherwise be more expensive or difficult to obtain.

Following the devastating hurricane seasons of 2004 and 2005, Florida recognized that the Cat Fund needed additional financial resources. The Legislature introduced a cash build-up mechanism to help accumulate reserves and reduce reliance on borrowing following catastrophic losses. The surcharge eventually reached 25% of the underlying FHCF reinsurance premium, where it remains today.

The surcharge is paid by insurance companies as part of their FHCF reinsurance expenses. Those expenses are ultimately reflected in the cost of providing property insurance to Florida homeowners.

However, the 25% surcharge does not mean homeowners are paying an additional 25% on their entire insurance premiums. It applies to one component of the insurer's overall expenses.

The Cat Fund's Own Research Raises Concerns

In July 2025, the FHCF published a white paper examining the importance of its cash build-up factor. According to that report, the surcharge generated approximately $3.7 billion in additional assets through the 2024 contract year, along with approximately $500 million in investment income. Together, those funds represent approximately $4.2 billion in additional financial resources.

That is a substantial amount of money.

The report also explains that eliminating the surcharge would increase the Fund's reliance on borrowing following major hurricane losses. When the Cat Fund does not have sufficient cash to satisfy its obligations, it may need to issue bonds backed by emergency assessments. Those assessments can ultimately affect a broad range of Florida insurance policyholders.

We have already experienced this problem. Following Hurricane Wilma, the FHCF borrowed approximately $2.65 billion, with repayment supported by emergency assessments that continued for years.

The lesson should be obvious. Building adequate reserves before a catastrophe is generally preferable to borrowing billions of dollars afterward and requiring policyholders to repay that debt.

How Much Money Are We Actually Talking About?

According to the FHCF's 2026 Ratemaking Formula Report, estimated annual reinsurance premiums, including the cash build-up factor, total approximately $1.346 billion.

Removing the 25% surcharge, assuming everything else remains unchanged, would reduce those FHCF reinsurance expenses by approximately $269 million annually.

That is real money, and Florida homeowners deserve to benefit from those savings.

However, there is an important distinction between reducing an insurance company's expenses and reducing a homeowner's premium. An insurer receiving lower reinsurance costs does not necessarily issue an immediate refund or reduce an existing policyholder's bill by the corresponding amount.

That is precisely why any reform must include a mandatory consumer protection mechanism.

My Proposal: Establish a Financial Floor and a Reserve Target

I have previously advocated restructuring and expanding the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund rather than simply maintaining its existing statutory limitations. My broader proposal includes increasing the Fund's coverage capacity, potentially doubling its current $17 billion limit to $34 billion over time, subject to actuarial and financial analysis.

However, increasing coverage capacity and accumulating sufficient cash reserves are two different things. A larger coverage limit does not automatically mean the Fund has enough money available to pay those losses without borrowing.

Florida needs a financial structure that accounts for the state's actual hurricane exposure, reconstruction costs, inflation, and modeled catastrophic losses. Rather than relying exclusively on a fixed statutory ceiling, the Fund should operate with actuarially established financial requirements and a clearly defined reserve target.

The 25% cash build-up factor should remain in place while the Fund accumulates the reserves necessary to meet that target.

Once the target is achieved, the surcharge should automatically be suspended.

There should be no need for another political debate, legislative delay, or discretionary decision. The financial conditions should determine when the surcharge is necessary.

If a future hurricane substantially reduces the Fund's reserves, the surcharge could be reinstated when reserves fall below a separately established minimum threshold. This would allow the Fund to rebuild its financial resources without requiring the surcharge to remain in effect indefinitely.

In other words, the surcharge should serve a defined financial purpose, not become a permanent expense without an established endpoint.

Insurance Companies Must Refund the Savings

This is perhaps the most important component of my proposal.

When the Cat Fund reaches its established reserve target and the 25% surcharge is suspended, insurance companies must be required by law to issue refund checks to policyholders for the actual savings attributable to that suspension.

Not promises of future rate reductions. Not vague assurances that lower operating expenses will eventually benefit consumers. Actual refunds based on documented savings.

The refunds would not be retroactive payments for surcharges collected in previous years. Those funds were collected to strengthen the Cat Fund and would remain available for that purpose.

Instead, insurers would return the savings they actually realize after the surcharge is suspended. The refund calculation would need to account for each carrier's FHCF reinsurance expenses and allocate the resulting savings fairly among affected policyholders.

The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation should verify those calculations, establish appropriate refund deadlines, and enforce compliance. Insurers should also be required to reflect the reduced reinsurance expenses in subsequent rate filings so policyholders are not charged for costs the insurers no longer incur.

Florida homeowners should not have to trust that insurance companies will voluntarily pass along the savings. The law should require it.

Why Not Just Eliminate the Surcharge Today?

I understand the appeal of eliminating the surcharge immediately. Homeowners are struggling with insurance costs, and any proposal promising relief deserves serious consideration.

However, the Cat Fund exists because Florida faces a unique concentration of hurricane risk. One major hurricane, or several hurricanes during the same season, can create billions of dollars in insured losses. Those obligations do not disappear simply because we want lower premiums.

Eliminating the surcharge before establishing adequate reserve requirements could leave the Fund more dependent on borrowing. Borrowing creates financing costs, and those costs can ultimately be recovered through emergency assessments.

That raises a fundamental question: Are we genuinely reducing the financial burden on Florida homeowners, or are we simply postponing part of that burden until after the next catastrophe?

My proposal addresses both sides of the equation. It allows the Fund to accumulate sufficient reserves while establishing a clear mechanism to suspend unnecessary collections and return the resulting savings to consumers.

It also avoids treating the surcharge as something that must either remain permanently or disappear permanently.

Florida Needs Long-Term Insurance Reform

Florida's property insurance challenges will not be resolved through a single surcharge reduction. Reinsurance expenses, claims costs, catastrophe exposure, insurer financial practices, and regulatory oversight all contribute to the cost of coverage.

Nevertheless, the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund is one area where meaningful structural reform is possible.

I support expanding the Fund's ability to protect Florida's insurance market, establishing financially sound reserve requirements, and ensuring that policyholders receive the economic benefits when those requirements are satisfied.

Governor-elect Donalds is correct to examine whether the cash build-up factor continues to serve its intended purpose. However, eliminating it immediately is not the only available solution.

We can preserve the financial stability of the Cat Fund while establishing a definite endpoint for the surcharge. We can require independent actuarial evaluations rather than relying on political assumptions. Most importantly, we can require insurance companies to return actual savings directly to the people paying the premiums.

Florida homeowners should not have to choose between affordable insurance today and financial protection tomorrow. A properly structured Cat Fund should provide both.

The objective should not simply be to eliminate a surcharge. It should be to create a financially responsible system that protects Florida homeowners, reduces unnecessary insurance expenses, and ensures that savings reach the people who deserve them.

That is the reform I believe Florida should pursue.

References

Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund. (2025). Retention and cash build-up factor: Tools to enhance the FHCF's cash resources and reduce reliance on debt. https://fhcf.sbafla.com/media/d2wn0jwk/20250721-white-paper-final.pdf

Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund. (2026). 2026 ratemaking formula report. https://flrules.org/gateway/reference.asp?No=Ref-19599

Insurance Journal. (2026, November 4). Georgia, Florida insurers facing new scrutiny, regulations after election. https://amp.insurancejournal.com/news/southeast/2026/11/04/891473.htm

WPTV. (2026). Donalds promises insurance cuts, defends data centers as race pivots to November. https://www.wptv.com/news/state/donalds-promises-insurance-cuts-defends-data-centers-as-race-pivots-to-november

Next
Next

Raising the Bar: A Proposal to Reform Florida's Insurance Adjusting Profession